« Eli Lilly's Brave Alzheimer's Talk |
| Pfizer's Gold Dust Makes it to the WSJ »
December 12, 2012
Sue the Nobel Committee. Yeah, That'll Work.
Rongxiang Xu is upset with this year's Nobel Prize award for stem cell research. He believes that work he did is so closely related to the subject of the prize that. . .he wants his name on it? No, apparently not. That he wants some of the prize money? Nope, not that either. That he thinks the prize was wrongly awarded? No, he's not claiming that.
What he's claiming is that the Nobel Committee has defamed his reputation as a stem cell pioneer by leaving him off, and he wants damages. Now, this is a new one, as far as I know. The closest example comes from 2003, when there was an ugly controversy over the award for NMR imaging (here's a post from the early days of this blog about it). Dr. Raymond Damadian took out strongly worded (read "hopping mad") advertisement in major newspapers claiming that the Nobel Committee had gotten the award wrong, and that he should have been on it. In vain. The Nobel Committee(s) have never backed down in such a case - although there have been some where you could make a pretty good argument - and they never will, as far as I can see.
Xu, who works in Los Angeles, is founder and chairman of the Chinese regenerative medicine company MEBO International Group. The company sells a proprietary moist-exposed burn ointment (MEBO) that induces "physiological repair and regeneration of extensively wounded skin," according to the company's website. Application of the wound ointment, along with other treatments, reportedly induces embryonic epidermal stem cells to grow in adult human skin cells. . .
. . .Xu's team allegedly awakened intact mature somatic cells to turn to pluripotent stem cells without engineering in 2000. Therefore, Xu claims, the Nobel statement undermines his accomplishments, defaming his reputation.
Now, I realize that I'm helping, in my small way, to give this guy publicity, which is one of the things he most wants out of this effort. But let me make myself clear - I'm giving him publicity in order to roll my eyes at him. I look forward to following Xu's progress through the legal system, and I'll bet his legal team looks forward to it as well, as long as things are kept on a steady payment basis.
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: Biological News
POST A COMMENT
- RELATED ENTRIES
- Merck's Aftermath
- Models and Reality
- Rewriting History at the Smithsonian?
- The FDA: Too Loose, Or Appropriately Brave?
- More Magic Methyls, Please
- Totaling Up a Job Search
- Humble Enzyme Dodges Spotlight
- Unraveling An Off-Rate