« A Total Mess At the FDA |
| When Is A Company Shading the Truth About Its Clinical Trials? »
July 24, 2012
Bapineuzumab Does Not Work Against Alzheimer's
This long, long story may finally be coming to an end. Immune-based therapies against beta-amyloid (and the associated amyloid plaques) have been in development for many years now (an excellent review here), and Elan has been in the thick of it for most of that time. Phase II results for this antibody came out in 2008 (here's the publication), and since then, everyone's been waiting to see if anything good would come of the phase III trials.
But not with a lot of hope. That's because the Phase II data weren't too encouraging, press releases aside. The subset of patients
with without the ApoE4 mutation showed what appeared to be some slowing in their rate of deterioration; the patients with have that mutation showed basically no beneficial effects at all (edited, got this reversed at first - DBL). There was a bit of biomarker data released earlier this year, which didn't convince people much one way or another. And now we have the numbers for the first of four Phase III trials.
Endpoints were not met - bapineuzumab seems to have definitely failed to help the patients in this study. Note that these were mild-to-moderate Alzheimer's patients who carry the ApoE4 mutation. There's another study going on with non-carriers, and two similar studies to these going on outside the US, but after this miss, what are the chances that they'll report anything beneficial?
No, if we were going to see something, you'd think that we'd have seen it here. Edit: not necessarily so, because the only hints of efficacy in Phase II were in ApoE4 noncarriers. But that wasn't all that convincing, and my own advice is still not to get any hopes up for the results of the next study).
There's another odd feature to this news: Elan was working with Wyeth, who were acquired by Pfizer. They then signed another development deal with J&J (Janssen) to spread the risk around. The trial results that came out yesterday were from the Janssen end of things (Pfizer's paying for the outside-the-US trials). But the press release was from Pfizer - as far as I can see, J&J has not sent out anything yet. And as for Elan, their press release is titled: "Elan Announces Pfizer’s Release of A Top-Line Result In First Of Four Bapineuzumab Phase 3 Trials". It says nothing about what that result might be - just that Pfizer released it, and it reminds people that more results are coming. Hmm. Was it agreed on that Pfizer would be the people to release these results? Or is that the sound of gritted teeth in the distance?
One other question: will this result finally shake the faith of the people who've been buying Elan stock all these years? Or was the failure of patients to respond the fault of hedge funds and short sellers instead? You know, the usual suspects. . .
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: Alzheimer's Disease | Clinical Trials
POST A COMMENT
- RELATED ENTRIES
- The Last Post
- The GSK Layoffs Continue, By Proxy
- The Move is Nigh
- Another Alzheimer's IPO
- Cutbacks at C&E News
- Sanofi Pays to Get Back Into Oncology
- An Irresponsible Statement About Curing Cancer
- Oliver Sacks on Turning Back to Chemistry