« Nobel Season 2010 |
| Open Thread »
September 28, 2010
Wisterone: A Structure I Can't Believe
You don't see an awful lot of chemistry publications from Vietnam. So in a way, I'm reluctant to call attention to this one, in the way that I'm about to. But it's in the preprint section of Bioorganic and Medicinal Chemistry Letters, and some of my far-flung correspondents have already picked up on it. So it's a bit too late to let it pass, I suppose.
The authors isolate a number of natural products from Wisteria (yep, the flowering woody vine one), and most of them are perfectly fine, if unremarkable. But their compound 1 (wisterone) is something else again.
Man, is that thing strained. Nothing with that carbon skeleton has ever been reported before (I just checked), outside of things that you can draw as part of the walls of fullerenes. I have a lot of trouble believing that this compound exists as shown - and if it does, then it deserves a lot more publicity than being tossed into a list inside a BOMCL paper - even though that journal is now getting a reputation for. . .interesting structural assignments.
This thing could get you into Angewandte Chemie or JACS, no problem. But the authors don't make much of it, just calling it a new compound, and presenting mass spec and NMR evidence for it. The 13C spectrum is perfectly reasonable for some sort of para-substituted aryl ring, but this compound would not give a perfectly reasonable spectrum, I would think. Surely all that strain would show up in some funny chemical shifts? Another oddity must be a misprint - they have the carbon shift of the carbonyl as 190.8, which is OK, I suppose, but they assign the methylenes as 190.8, which can't be right. (The protons come at 4.48).
No, I really think something is wrong here. I don't have a structure to propose, off the top of my head (not without resolving that weirdo methylene carbon shift), but I don't think it's this. Anyone?
Update: just noticed that this is said to be a crystalline compound, melting point of 226-228. I find it hard to imagine any structure like this taking that much heat, but. . .it's a crystal! Get an X-ray structure. No one's going to believe it without one, and BOMCL should never have let this paper through without someone asking for at least that. . .
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: Analytical Chemistry | Chemical News
POST A COMMENT
- RELATED ENTRIES
- Gitcher SF5 Groups Right Here
- Changing A Broken Science System
- One and Done
- The Latest Protein-Protein Compounds
- Professor Fukuyama's Solvent Peaks
- Novartis Gets Out of RNAi
- Total Synthesis in Flow
- Sweet Reason Lands On Its Face