« Are You Now, Or Have You Ever Been. . .? |
| Thoughts on What Used to Be Schering-Plough »
November 5, 2009
What Exactly Does Resveratrol Do?
Resveratrol's a mighty interesting compound. It seems to extend lifespan in yeast and various lower organisms, and has a wide range of effects in mice. Famously, GlaxoSmithKline has expensively bought out Sirtris, a company whose entire research program started with resveratrol and similar compound that modulate the SIRT1 pathway.
But does it really do that? The picture just got even more complicated. A group at Amgen has published a paper saying that when you look closely, resveratrol doesn't directly affect SIRT1 at all. Interestingly, this conclusion has been reached before (by a group at the University of Washington), and both teams conclude that the problem is the fluorescent peptide substrate commonly used in sirtuin assays. With the fluorescent group attached, everything looks fine - but when you go to the extra trouble of reading things out without the fluorescent tag, you find that resveratrol doesn't seem to make SIRT1 do anything to what are supposed to be its natural substrates.
"The claim of resvertraol being a SIRT1 activator is likely to be an experimental artifact of the SIRT1 assay that employs the Fluor de Lys-SIRT1 peptide as a substrate. However, the beneficial metabolic effects of resveratrol have been clearly demonstrated in diabetic animal models. Our data do not support the notion that these metabolic effects are mediated by direct SIRT1 activation. Rather, they could be mediated by other mechanisms. . ."
They suggest activation of AMPK (an important regulatory kinase that's tied in with SIRT1) as one such mechanism, but admit that they have no idea how resveratrol might activate it. Does that process still require SIRT1 at all? Who knows? One thing I think I do know is that this has something to do with this Amgen paper from 2008 on new high-throughput assays for sirtuin enzymes.
One wonders what assay formats Sirtris has been using to evaluate their new compounds, and one also wonders what they make of all this now at GSK. Does one not? We can be sure, though, that there are plenty of important things that we don't know yet about sirtuins and the compounds that affect them. It's going to be quite a ride as we find them out, too.
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: Aging and Lifespan | Biological News | Drug Assays
POST A COMMENT
- RELATED ENTRIES
- Sydney Brenner on the State of Science
- A Bit More Realism in Consulting
- Out to Illinois
- A Call To Rein In Phase III Trials
- Computational Nirvana
- A Close Look at Receptor Signaling
- The Instructive Case of Galena Biopharma
- Changes in Papers