« Ariad's Patent Rises From the Grave to Smite the Living |
| Rings of the Future! »
August 26, 2009
Thalidomide for Myeloma: Whose Idea Was It?
So, if you're a patient with a rare disease (or a relative of a patient with one), and you have an idea for repurposing an old drug for treatment. . .and you get a company interested, and it actually works. . .works to the point that the company takes in a billion or two dollars a year. . .what then?
Some readers will have guessed that I'm talking about thalidomide and Celgene, and right they are. Beth Jacobsen is the person involved - her husband died of multiple myeloma, but her medical sleuthing had turned up the idea of using thalidomide as a therapy for the disease, and she kept up the pressure to have the idea tried out. Celgene's mentioned her in annual reports, and she's been thanked by name in a publication on the clinical results.
But now she's suing Celgene, saying that they misappropriated her idea. Complicating the issue is the question of whether the late Judah Folkman was really the source of the inspiration, in a phone conversation with Jacobsen (earlier versions of the story have it that way, but the lawsuit apparently tells it differently). Which way did it happen? Is Jacobsen indeed owed compensation? And whether she is or not, will she be able to convince a court? Matt Herper has the story at Forbes.
I'll defer my own comments until I know a bit more about the case, but this is definitely an interesting one. I can add something that might be of relevance, though: a search in PubMed for "thalidomide myeloma" turns up 64 pages of references, almost all of them post-1999. But there is this one, from Italy in 1963. Has the idea been around for that long? Someone who can track down that journal can tell us. . .
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: Cancer | Drug Development | Drug Industry History | Patents and IP
POST A COMMENT
- RELATED ENTRIES
- A Last Summer Day Off
- The Early FDA
- Drug Repurposing
- The Smallest Drugs
- Life Is Too Short For Some Journal Feeds
- A New Look at Phenotypic Screening
- Small Molecules - Really, Really Small
- InterMune Bought