« European Drugs, American Drugs |
| Over There, Behind That Stack of Whatchamacallits »
July 17, 2007
Visfatin: Real Or Not?
A commentor to my Proteomics 101 post the other day brought up an important point: that before you can have a chance to figure out what a protein is doing, you have to know that it exists. Finding the darn things is no small job, since you're digging through piles of chemically similar stuff to unearth them. What's more, we can't just ignore 'em: some of the low-concentration proteins are also correspondingly important and powerful.
Nasty arguments can erupt over whether a given protein and its proposed functions even exist. Crockery is flying over one of those right now, an insulin-like protein hormone dubbed "visfatin" by its discoverers in Osaka a couple of years ago. Well, in this case the protein probably exists, but does it do what it's advertised to do? An insulin mimic secreted by fat cells would be worth knowing about, but there doesn't seem to be enough of it present in the blood to do much of anything, given how well it binds to its putative targets. There are also reports that some of that data in the Osaka paper are hard to reproduce.
Complicating things even more is the (apparently well-founded) contention that visfatin is a re-discovery of a protein already known as PBEF, which is identical to another protein named Nampt. (Each "discovering" group assigned their own name, a situation that happens so often in biology that people don't even notice it any more).
The whipped topping on the whole thing is a accusation of misconduct by someone in Japan, which led to an investigation by Osaka University, which has now recommended that the original paper be retracted. Its lead author, Iichiro Shimomura, does not agree, as you might well imagine. The points of contention are many: whether the misconduct was real at all, or whether it describes real events that don't rise to the level of misconduct, or whether the conclusions of the paper are invalidated or not by them, and so on.
An early solution appears unlikely. And we still don't know what exactly visfatin/PBEF/Nampt is doing. Next time you wonder how things are going over in the proteome, consider this one.
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: Biological News | Diabetes and Obesity | The Dark Side
POST A COMMENT
- RELATED ENTRIES
- How Not to Do It: NMR Magnets
- Allergan Escapes Valeant
- Vytorin Actually Works
- Fatalities at DuPont
- The New York TImes on Drug Discovery
- How Are Things at Princeton?
- Phage-Derived Catalysts
- Our Most Snorted-At Papers This Month. . .