« Failure: Not Your Friend, But Definitely Your Companion |
| Linkage! »
April 3, 2007
You know, small-molecule folks like me are going to have to learn to deal with immunology. I don't mind saying that it's not my field - yet - but who knows, perhaps it will be. The recent successes of Dendreon and (today) Cell Genesys prompt these thoughts. Both companies have shown useful efficacy with immune-based prostate cancer therapies, good enough to make you wonder how effective these things will eventually be when we understand more about what's going on.
As things stand, there are a bewildering number of possibilities. Both of these vaccines depend on production of GM-CSF secreting cells (a powerful cytokine which stimulates white blood cell production and activity), but they're rather different otherwise. Dendreon's Provenge is autologous, that is, derived from each patient's own cells, for one thing, while the Cell Genesys GVAX vaccine isn't individualized at all (that is, allogeneic). That's just the first choice to make. There are all sorts of options about what kinds of cells to use, which antigens to decorate them with and what proteins to have them secrete, how to administer them to patients singly and in combination with other conventional chemotherapies, and so on. This work has been going on for years now, and I've no doubt that a lot of blind alleys have been followed. And a lot more will get followed, too, but the results so far are pretty impressive. They're beating the small-molecule conventional therapies in the difficult cases, that much is clear. It's important to remember that the patients are still dying of cancer, but they're taking noticeably longer to do it, which is success in our era.
We'll probably see a rush into the stocks of every company that has both "cancer" and "vaccine" in its 10-K filings, but I'd say be careful. For example, if you bought Cell Genesys last week, you're quite happy. But if you bought it this time last year, you're still in the red. Although I find these current results quite interesting, the field is still very young indeed. Companies are targeting prostate cancer because it's a non-essential organ (so it doesn't matter if the immune system trashes it), but they're also going to be going after tumors in rather more vital organs like the lung and pancreas. Development of immune therapies in those areas is going to be full of more excitement than some of the stockholders will be ready for.
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: Business and Markets | Cancer
POST A COMMENT
- RELATED ENTRIES
- Molecular Printing of Drug Molecules. Say What?
- Pfizer Walks Again By Night
- Gitcher SF5 Groups Right Here
- Changing A Broken Science System
- One and Done
- The Latest Protein-Protein Compounds
- Professor Fukuyama's Solvent Peaks
- Novartis Gets Out of RNAi